Monolith Preservation Brief — February 2025
The Trellis Walk Civic Library was designed by T. H. Mander and completed in 1968. Its board-marked béton brut elevations, expressed structural frame, and cantilevered reading room represent a considered application of the New Brutalist programme to a civic brief — not the careless repetition that critics cite when condemning the entire movement to rubble.
Under paragraph 195 of the National Planning Policy Framework, demolition of a non-designated heritage asset requires the applicant to demonstrate that the public benefits outweigh the harm. The Council's viability assessment of February 2024 fails this test on two counts: it undervalues the community use evidence by a factor of three, and it does not consider adaptive reuse scenarios modelled in the 2022 structural survey by Arup, which identified a serviceable life of at least 80 further years at a remediation cost of £2.3 million — against a new-build cost of £14.7 million for equivalent floor area.
A Georgian terrace is not preserved because it is old. It is preserved because it is irreplaceable. So is this.
Monolith submitted a counter-representation to the Planning Inspectorate on 6 March 2025. The appeal is ongoing. This is what we do: we build the evidentiary record, cite the planning law, commission the structural data, and stand in the room when the decision is made.
Read the Case Files